Fantastic warm sticky bun, perfect to share — next time we will skip the other (mediocre) local spots and have lunch there!
Elaine P.3/10/25
They are absolutely delicious. I’ve never had anything like it before and I would recommend them to anyone who is in the Williamsport area to go by and try them if they haven’t already. I will be making an order to have shipped to me so that I have more on hand. I have already run out of them. I’m hooked on them !
Tim C.11/13/24
Food is delicious, it is a warm welcoming environment, and the service is fantastic. Really made me and my daughters day.
Bunnybonkers H.10/7/23
This place is sticky bun heaven. I was in town for the LLWS and found this place on Yelp. It’s kind of tucked behind another building but is definitely worth any effort needed to locate. I ordered the Walnut Sticky Bun and a cup of the (very good) house coffee and was completely blown away. Hands down the best sticky bun I’ve ever had. I brought some home for the family to experience and they’re now big fans of Mr Sticky’s too. I will definitely be taking advantage of their nationwide shipping.
Dave J.8/23/22
RUN, don’t walk, okay, maybe sprint so you don’t hurt yourself – and find a Mr. Sticky’s Fair Stand near you or drive to Williamsport, PA to their headquarters to enjoy the BEST STICKY BUNS you will EVER have in your life! I am not kidding. When the sticky bun cuts with a FORK and pulls apart like pulling apart a cotton ball with that gooey brown sugar and cinnamon wrapped around the dough…you know you are in Sticky Bun Heaven. Want to know how GREAT these are? I shipped a dozen to my husband and I in NJ. Yea, they are THAT good and reheat very well. You won’t be disappointed. Their logo is “extremely addictive” – and I think based on my review you’ll agree I’m addicted. They serve great coffee and made a wonderful Cafe Latte for us (at the headquarters). Perfect pairing for a fresh sticky bun. In addition to a plain sticky bun, you can get one topped with nuts, a cinnamon bun (plain, cream cheese icing or peanut butter icing) and so much more. Enjoy!
Alanna B.9/15/21
The reviews don’t lie, these are the most amazing cinnamon buns I’ve EVER had. They are HUGE in diameter and height, and have an insane amount of cinnamon in them. SOoooooo good. We had the maple and peanut butter flavored spreads, both were extremely good. So glad we stopped there!
O.M.G.- saphyress
This is a seriously great pastry- go hungry, because you will want more than one! I took a bag of home and it was a feeding frenzy after the first bite!
Best Stickies Ever!- cynthis2014/b>
These are the best sticky buns I have EVER had. They are huge so they are great for sharing. I took some back to my hotel to have with my morning coffee. Can’t say enough. Umm Umm GOOOOD.
The best sticky buns I have EVER had- 333dawneb
This was our second visit to Mr. Sticky from our home an hour away. No Fall trip to Lancaster would be complete without bringing home this taste bud orgasm of sweet perfection. The dough is just so fresh and the cinnamon and sugar so perfectly blended. As a “restaurant”, Mr Sticky ranks #1 of 532 restaurants in the Lancaster area on the Trip Advisor website. Quite a commendation for its quality, customer satisfaction and business model. In closing, I spent $80 for a fine dining meal for two at a nearby restaurant which ranked in the 50’s for a Trip Advisor rating, I spent $5 for two sticky buns and got just as much satisfaction! Amazing!!
Mr. Sticky, the filet mignon of cinnamon buns- Jack D
We are local and we tell many people about these wonderful Sticky Buns. They are the best and we especially enjoy the ones with walnuts on top.
The BEST- Carol and Ray L
This is a must do for our family. Any time you can stop and get sticky buns to bring home you will be a hit. We order a dozen “mini” buns every Christmas. They easily serve 8-10.
Sweet tooth fix- Melissa W
These are some of the best sticky buns I have ever had. From the nuts to the cream cheese they make you want to get more.
Sweet and sticky never tasted so good- Bill T.